Dr. Natalyn Gibbs has been recognized by Education Insider as the recipient of “Top 10 School Superintendents in Pennsylvania - 2026,” based on a defined selection methodology reflecting their leadership, professional impact, and standing within the industry. This profile has been developed by the Education Insider research and editorial team based on insights from an interview with Dr. Natalyn Gibbs, Superintendent.

Dr. Natalyn Gibbs

Superintendent, Erie Public Schools

Placing Relationships at the Heart of Leadership

Dr. Natalyn Gibbs

With nearly 25 years in education, Dr. Natalyn Gibbs brings a teacher-first philosophy to leading one of the region’s largest public school systems, where relationships, stakeholder engagement and purposeful leadership shape student success.

As the first woman to serve as superintendent and CEO of Erie Public Schools, Dr. Gibbs recognizes the significance of her position and the importance of showing up for the community she serves. Over the years, she has worked with some of the lowest-performing schools, helping them move from the bottom five percent to reward status or the state’s highest designation.

Currently, she oversees approximately 11,000 students, more than 2,000 staff members and thousands of contracted personnel.

No two days look the same. From planning and accountability to school visits and problem-solving, her work takes her from district-level decisions to the realities of individual schools.

Despite the demands of the role, Dr. Gibbs remains a teacher first and forever. Her experience in education has shaped her belief that leadership begins and ends with relationships. She carries that belief into her work with senior leaders and school teams, building their capacity and staying connected to what teachers and students need.

Building a Village around Students

Dr. Gibbs sees families, community organizations and local stakeholders as integral to public education, as schools cannot do life-changing work alone.

Parents play an important role in students’ learning and educational success. Rather than simply outlining expectations, she wants the district to help parents understand how the educational system works, what questions to ask, where to advocate and what protocols to follow when they cannot access needed support. This, she believes, helps them better support their children and reinforce important areas of their education.

Equally important is stakeholder engagement. Erie Public Schools’ new strategic plan was developed with input from approximately 55 stakeholders over six months and approved in April. As the district prepares to put the plan into action for the 2026– 27 school year, one of its five core priorities is family engagement, which also includes the wider community.

The district is also revamping its community partnership framework to welcome individuals and organizations with programs, talent and ideas that align with the plan and help meet its key performance indicators.

Returning Students to Learning

As an urban district, Erie Public Schools continues to address the decline in student engagement following COVID-19. The district’s “return to learn” initiative is focused on rebuilding students’ engagement with peers and teachers.

Over the summer, the district held five engagement sessions on limiting the use of electronic devices and standard school attire. Each reached capacity, drawing 300 to 400 parents.

The district’s efforts to encourage face-to-face interaction have shown early signs of progress. After about a month of school, educators thanked Dr. Gibbs for helping them get to know students better and build stronger relationships. Executive principals also reported more conversations among students in cafeterias. The initiative aims to create future-ready learners by strengthening communication, collaboration, problem-solving and critical-thinking skills.

Dr. Gibbs’ vision for future-ready students also focuses on literacy, a fundamental civil right. It helps students access other subject areas and make informed choices about college or career paths. She also connects students’ educational progress to wider outcomes, including workforce development, better mental health, wage-sustaining jobs and home ownership. Her goal is for students to graduate ready to contribute to the workforce, giving local employers confidence in the talent coming from the district.

Listening, Learning and Leading with Purpose

For aspiring leaders, Dr. Gibbs emphasizes three principles: listen, learn and lead with purpose.

Putting those principles into practice means slowing down to ensure investments have the greatest impact on teaching and learning. It also requires staying connected to stakeholders and building the culture and support systems schools need to address.

Students and families are counting on educational leaders to get the work right. She urges leaders to bring passion to their work, translating their commitment into meaningful improvements for schools and communities and, ultimately, better experiences for students.

By building excellence together, educators and leaders can create the conditions for staff to thrive and students to succeed.